Found him on the 1850 Benton, Yates, New York census (img 81) as Theodore Bain
age 1. He and his parents are living with his mother Hannah's parents, Jeremiah
and Eva Finger
Found him on the 1870 Benton, Yates, New York census (img 40) age 20, living with his parents.
Found him on the 1900 Gorham, Ontario, New York census (dist 66 img 13) age 50, bar tender.