Found him on the 1900 Pulteney, Steuben, New York census (dist 103 img 29) age 49.
Found him on the 1910 Pulteney, Steuben, New York census (dist 153 img 39) age 54, farmer, fruit farm.
Prattsburgh, March 24 - Orlando Overhiser, 74, many years active as a farmer and vineyardist in the town of Pulteney, died last night. He leaves his wife two daughters, Mrs. Ward Finger and Mrs. L.Doty two sons Sluman and Byron of Pulteney, and a brother, Leroy Overhiser of Bath. Funeral at Pulteney Thursday at 2 o'clock. - Rochester Democrat and Chronicle March 25, 1931